Wednesday, January 19, 2000 - Page updated at 12:00 AM
More Israeli Conscientious Objectors
AP
JERUSALEM - Lotan Raz was born on an Israeli communal farm but grew up on the lore of the 1960s U.S. protest movement, so when the 18-year-old received his Israeli draft card in the mail, he did his duty - went to the induction center and said his conscience did not allow him to serve.
Raz spent 52 days in a military prison after the army refused to recognize him as a conscientious objector.
Just a few years ago, young men such as Raz were an exception in a nation that has fought six wars in its 51-year history. But today, Israel is more prosperous and sure of itself, less of a garrison state.
While the vast majority of young Israeli men still do three years of compulsory service, many even volunteering for combat duty, a growing number seek to avoid the draft.
Some say they are pacifists, while others acknowledge they want to get on with their careers and not spend three years doing something they don't believe in.
In general, the army grants conscientious-objector status to women, but not to men, and those who are turned down by a special army review panel are sent to jail.
"The willingness to serve in the army is in decline," said Gad Barzilai, a political scientist and author who researches the relationship between the Israeli army and society. "I think the army is very concerned and, for good reason."
However, as external threats to Israel recede, the army may be less insistent than in the past to recruit every able-bodied 18-year-old, said social commentator Daniel Elazar.
Since the founding of the state, only Jewish seminary students and Israel's Arab citizens have been exempt from service. Raz, recognized as an Amnesty International "prisoner of conscience," said he felt the need to take a stand on principles.
He was ultimately dismissed by the army as "unsuitable for service," without mention of his objections to serving in the West Bank, Gaza Strip or southern Lebanon.
Still, the idea of challenging compulsory service does not come easy in a country where the military helped forge the national character. The sight of rifle-toting soldiers on the city streets is part of the national landscape.
Moshe Mugrabi, 34, said that when he was drafted as an 18-year-old, he did not realize that refusing to serve was an option. Mugrabi, an Internet designer from Tel Aviv, completed three years in a combat unit.
But when he returned to Israel after four years at art school in Berlin, he found himself incapable of returning to his unit for reserve duty and was released by an army psychologist. "I could not go on in an army framework of orders," Mugrabi said.
Copyright (c) 2000 Seattle Times Company, All Rights Reserved.
![]()

- Amazon’s plan for giant spheres gets mixed reaction
- No question: Russell Wilson's in charge now
- Pete Carroll on Seahawks' off-field problems: "It's real serious"
- Records: Slain intruder showed signs of mental breakdown
- Police: Brother-in-law ‘heavily involved’ in disposal of Susan Powell’s body
- Burt Bacharach opens up on daughter's suicide
- Ex-Great Wolf Lodge lifeguard charged with rape of guest, 14
- Is Catholic Church taking over health care in Washington? | Danny Westneat
- Man shot to death while questioned in Boston probe
- UW Medicine, Catholic health system to have ‘strategic affiliation’
- Game thread: Aaron Harang tries to halt Mariners slide
310 - Is Catholic Church taking over health care in Washington?
270 - Official: Treasury played no role in IRS targeting
153 - Podcast: Mariners season hits crucial point
140 - Amazon.com proposing glass-and-steel spheres
111 - Businesses refuse service to gays
105 - Mike Trout hits for cycle; Mariners hit rock bottom...again
91 - Mariners shuffle lineup, put Bay at leadoff and Morse at No. 3
82 - GOP questions IRS scrutiny of anti-abortion groups
65 - Game thread: Mariners try to end trip with a win
60
- UW Medicine, Catholic health system to have ‘strategic affiliation’
- Is Catholic Church taking over health care in Washington? | Danny Westneat
- Amazon’s plan for giant spheres gets mixed reaction
- Kemper Freeman plans $1.2 billion expansion in Bellevue
- UW expands online courses, this time from Harvard, MIT
- Catholic schools update to compete with charter schools
- China’s wealthy paying cash for Eastside luxury homes
- Italy on the plate by way of Ballard | Taste
- deafReview gives a voice to deaf consumers
- Earthquake scenarios show potential for huge damage, loss of life



