Friday, November 25, 2005 - Page updated at 12:00 AM
Book Review
Frank McCourt's classroom memoirs in "Teacher Man"
Special to The Seattle Times

MARY ALTAFFER / AP
Author Frank McCourt taught in New York public schools for 30 years.
"Teacher Man"
by Frank McCourt
Scribner, 258 pp., $26
Frank McCourt knows what it's like to be, in his own words, the "mick of the moment." He's won a Pulitzer, a National Book Critics Circle Award and a host of other honors. His memoirs have sold millions of copies and been translated into 30 languages.
But McCourt hasn't lost touch with his roots. "Angela's Ashes," after all, was about his hardscrabble childhood in Ireland. "'Tis" chronicled his coming of age on the docks of 1950s New York, as an American GI in Germany and as a student working his way through New York University.
Once he finally earned his degree, McCourt didn't settle for a career on Easy Street. Instead he spent three decades as a high-school English instructor in New York City's public-school system. Now his third memoir recalls those years and pays tribute to what, he laments, is too often regarded as "the downstairs maid of professions." "Teacher Man" is the McCourt you've come to expect: wry, rambling, charming, rueful.
Chalk it up to his father's abandonment of the family when McCourt was still a kid; or maybe to the schoolyard bullies, castigating priests and harsh schoolmasters of his youth; or perhaps even to the dock workers whose "generosity of belly and heart" he never felt he could emulate — McCourt is a master at self-deprecation.
He describes himself variously as an ass, a poltroon, a "two-faced blathering mick," an aimless "periphery man." "No vision, no plan, no goal," he grumbles. "Just amble to the crypt, man. Fade and leave no legacy ... "
But really, he knows better than that. In spite of the detours in his personal life and the missteps in his education — in teaching he finds his way. As a beginning teacher, he quickly learns that the smug theories meted out by his education professors at NYU have little to do with life in the classroom. He casts aside the useless advice and learns to navigate his own way.
Suddenly, the storm-tossed Atlantic crossings of his earlier years pale in comparison with the choppy seas of a high-school classroom. Academic apathy, hormone-driven angst, flying sandwiches, dozing students and an occasional "ecstasy of plagiarism" — he learns to deal with it all.
As a creative-writing instructor struggling to motivate his classes, McCourt hits upon an epiphany when a student hands him a bogus excuse note with a parent's forged signature. He already has a drawer filled with "These gems of fiction, fantasy, creativity, crawthumping, self-pity, family problems, boilers exploding. "
Realizing that this is creative writing at its best, he turns excuse notes into assignments. The students' responses are inspired.
In McCourt's classes, cookbooks might become templates for poetry, poems might become templates for life, and life — McCourt's own life — becomes the subject of stories he tells his classes to keep them engaged, to keep them coming back, to give them perspectives beyond the bounds of the neighborhoods they've grown up in. He gets in trouble for this on more than one occasion. Sometimes he even gets fired for failing to stick to the curriculum.
But McCourt wants his students to learn something more important than conjugation. "Whatever ideas they had came from the avalanche of media in our world," he frets. "No one had ever told them they had a right to think for themselves."
"Teacher Man" is a fiercely irrepressible celebration of a noble enterprise, the results of which can't always be quantified or measured by standardized tests. The reader cannot miss McCourt's expansive belief that, when it comes to getting the message across to students, passion for a subject will trump austere professionalism just about every time.
To conclude, this retired creative-writing teacher offers advice consecrated by the magnificent trilogy of memoirs he has gifted us with over the last decade.
"Every moment of your life, you're writing," he says.
"You are your material."
Copyright © 2005 The Seattle Times Company
![]()

- David Stern's Seattle sucker punch shows we must stop being a pawn in NBA's game | Jerry Brewer
- Mayor: Kings deal about 'not letting somebody take something that isn't theirs'
- Seattle’s failed bid: No NBA, no promises
- Great Wolf Lodge ex-lifeguard held in alleged rape of guest, 14
- North Bend intruder had job, was father of five
- Pot rules taking shape; public gets a taste of what’s ahead
- Mariners beat Yankees again, near .500
- Ex-student sues Tacoma schools over restroom sex
- GE, Boeing tell airlines to inspect some 777 engines for defect
- Boston bombing suspect’s note explains motive, officials say
- Kings moving closer to sale to Sacramento group
346 - Game thread: Mariners try to contain high-octane Indians
296 - Hood River, Ore., bakery won’t make cake for lesbians
260 - House committee to grill ousted IRS chief
256 - SI report --- Hansen offered deposit back, declines to take it
128 - Another new Husky? Blakley gives commitment to UW
118 - Why is any political group exempt from paying taxes?
90 - Mariners have been here before, but this feels different
79 - LGBT students get $600,000 in scholarships from 2 groups
27 - Burgess quits mayor's race
26
- Pot rules taking shape; public gets a taste of what’s ahead
- Columbia Hills State Park is a Gorge wonder
- LGBT students get $600,000 in scholarships from 2 groups
- Why is any political group exempt from taxes?
- Contractor at Wade’s gun range cited for lead exposure
- Marine, dog partner reunited in surprise ceremony
- Sex-with-animals advocate told to stay off Internet
- Helping high-school students navigate the next step | Lynne K. Varner / Times editorial columnist
- Tableau Software shares soar 64% in trading debut
- Italy on the plate by way of Ballard | Taste





