Sunday, March 9, 2008 - Page updated at 12:00 AM
Bush vetoes restriction on CIA interrogations
The Associated Press
WASHINGTON — Democrats and human-rights advocates criticized President Bush's veto Saturday of a bill that would have banned the CIA from using simulated drowning and other coercive interrogation methods to gain information from suspected terrorists.
Bush said such tactics have helped foil terrorist plots. His critics likened some methods to torture and said they sullied America's reputation around the world.
"This president had the chance to end the torture debate for good, yet he chose instead to leave the door open to use torture in the future," said Democratic Sen. Dianne Feinstein of California, a member of the Senate Intelligence Committee.
She said Bush ignored the advice of 43 retired generals and admirals and 18 national-security experts, including former secretaries of state and national-security advisers, who supported the bill.
"Torture is a black mark against the United States," she said.
The bill would have limited the CIA to 19 interrogation techniques used by the military and spelled out in the Army Field Manual. Bush said he vetoed the measure because it is important for the CIA to have a separate and classified interrogation program for suspected terrorists who possess critical information about possible plots against the United States.
Bush, who used his weekly radio address to announce the veto, said the program had helped stop plots against a Marine camp in Djibouti and the U.S. consulate in Karachi, Pakistan, and plans to fly passenger planes into a Los Angeles tower or London's Heathrow Airport and city buildings.
"Were it not for this program, our intelligence community believes that al-Qaida and its allies would have succeeded in launching another attack against the American homeland," the president said.
Bush's veto — the ninth of his presidency, but the eighth in the past 10 months with Democrats in control of Congress — underscored his determination to preserve many of the executive prerogatives his administration has claimed in the name of fighting terrorism, and to cement them into law.
Bush is now fighting with Congress over the expansion of powers under the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act and over the depth of the U.S. security commitments to Iraq once the U.N. mandate for the international forces there expires at the end of the year.
House Speaker Nancy Pelosi said the nation's ability to lead the world depends on its morality, not military might. "We will begin to reassert that moral authority by attempting to override the president's veto next week," said Pelosi, D-Calif.
Based on the margin of passage in each chamber, it may prove difficult for the Democratic-controlled Congress to turn back Bush's veto. It takes a two-thirds majority, and the vote was 222-199 in the House and 51-45 in the Senate.
Bush said he did not veto the bill specifically over waterboarding, a technique that simulates drowning. The Army banned the use of waterboarding or sensory deprivation on uncooperative prisoners in 2006. The CIA, which also prohibited the practice in 2006, has acknowledged using waterboarding on three suspected terrorists in 2003.
"My disagreement ... is not over any particular interrogation technique; for instance, it is not over waterboarding, which is not part of the current CIA program," Bush said in his veto message to the House. The attorney general has deemed that program legal under domestic and international law, he said.
Still, waterboarding remains in the CIA's tool kit. The technique can be used, but it requires the consent of the attorney general and president on a case-by-case basis. Bush wants to keep that option open.
"I cannot sign into law a bill that would prevent me, and future presidents, from authorizing the CIA to conduct a separate, lawful intelligence program, and from taking all lawful actions necessary to protect Americans from attack," Bush said in a statement.
Democrats say the CIA should be restricted to the techniques in the Army Field Manual. They include the "good cop-bad cop" routine; making prisoners think they are in another country's custody; and separating a prisoner from others for up to 30 days.
In addition to waterboarding, the field manual prohibits putting hoods on prisoners or putting duct tape across their eyes; stripping prisoners naked; and forcing prisoners to perform or mimic sexual acts. It also prohibits beating, burning or physically hurting prisoners in other ways; subjecting them to hypothermia or mock executions. It does not allow food, water and medical treatment to be withheld. Dogs may not be used in interrogation.
Copyright © 2008 The Seattle Times Company
![]()

- Seattle’s NBA hopes still high as league warms to expansion
- China’s wealthy paying cash for Eastside luxury homes
- Sex-with-animals advocate told to stay off Internet
- Navy dolphins discover rare old torpedo off Calif. coast near Coronado
- Dark, massive asteroid to fly by Earth on May 31
- Review: Despite sleek design, HTC One disappoints
- Man survives bear attack after wife cracks it on head
- An innocent slip of the (long, slinky) tongue by NBA honcho | The Wrap / Ron Judd
- Seattle Sounders knock off FC Dallas, 4-2, to extend unbeaten streak to six
- It’s time to limit presidency to one term | Danny Westneat
- IRS office was perplexed, inundated with tax-exempt applications
241 - Game thread: Felix Hernandez looks to halt Mariners skid
187 - Mariners seeing what that crucial speed element looks like
151 - Seattle’s NBA hopes still high as league warms to expansion
143 - It’s time to limit presidency to one term
110 - Premiums under new health-care law remain about the same
108 - China’s wealthy paying cash for Eastside luxury homes
105 - Aide: Obama learned about IRS from news accounts
57 - Editorial: Wake up the IRS watchdogs
52 - Tea party looks to take advantage of moment
22
- China’s wealthy paying cash for Eastside luxury homes
- Columbia Hills State Park is a Gorge wonder
- Premiums under new health-care law remain about the same
- 129 concerts to see this summer
- Diversity means opportunity in Tukwila
- Fremont: Quirky, lively and very popular | NW Neighborhood
- The stories behind Huntington’s disease | Nicole & Co.
- Navy dolphins discover rare old torpedo off Calif. coast near Coronado
- Sex-with-animals advocate told to stay off Internet
- Cancer survivor exudes calm in Legislature’s budget battles



